Liberty Mutual and Liberty Life Long Term Disability Claims, Denials, and Appeals

If you have a long term disability policy issued by Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston, or you have been searching for help with a Liberty Mutual disability denial, there is something you should know before you go any further: Liberty Mutual no longer handles these claims.
That does not mean your coverage went away. Your policy is intact and your rights under it are intact. What changed is the company on the other side of the claim. In this article, we'll discuss who insures your policy now, why the confusion is so common, why these claims get denied, and what to do about a denial.
The Maddox Firm handles these claims regardless of which name is on your paperwork. If you filed a claim and it was denied, or benefits you had been receiving were terminated, we can help you appeal. If you have already appealed and received a final denial, we can handle your litigation.
The Maddox Firm has extensive experience with claims on Liberty Life policies, both before and after Lincoln took over the business. We have obtained approvals for clients at the initial claim stage and on appeal, in matters involving a wide range of medical conditions.
Does Liberty Mutual Still Write Long Term Disability Insurance?
No. Liberty Mutual sold its entire group benefits operation, including group long term disability, group life, dental, vision, and absence management, to Lincoln Financial. The sale closed on May 1, 2018, when Lincoln acquired Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston, the entity that had issued those policies.
Liberty Mutual today is a property and casualty insurer. Its business lines are auto, home, commercial property and casualty, commercial auto, workers' compensation, and related coverages. It does not sell group life or group disability insurance.
One exception causes real confusion. Liberty Mutual remains a major workers' compensation insurer. If you are dealing with Liberty Mutual over a work-related injury, that is a workers' compensation claim, and it is a different kind of claim from a long term disability claim, with different rules, a different process, and different deadlines. It is possible to have both at the same time, with two different companies.
Who Insures Your Liberty Life Long Term Disability Policy Now?
The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company, or Lincoln Life & Annuity Company of New York for New York policies.
The chain of events runs like this:
May 1, 2018. Lincoln acquired Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston from Liberty Mutual.
September 1, 2019. The company was renamed Lincoln Life Assurance Company of Boston. Nothing about the company or its policies changed.
October 1, 2021. Lincoln Life Assurance Company of Boston merged into The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company, which assumed all of its obligations. The state of domicile moved from New Hampshire to Indiana. Policyholders received an endorsement stating that all other terms and benefits of their policy remained unchanged.
Your policy did not change. The definition of disability, the elimination period, the 24 month limitations, the offsets, and your appeal rights are whatever your certificate says. A sale does not rewrite the contract.
Lincoln Life Assurance Company of Boston no longer exists as a separate company. A great deal of published material still names it as the insurer. If you are preparing an appeal or a lawsuit, direct it at the surviving entity.
Liberty Mutual is not the right party. Sending an appeal to Liberty Mutual will not preserve your rights, and your appeal deadline will keep running while it sits in the wrong place.
Everything about how these claims are actually handled now belongs on our Lincoln Financial long term disability page, which covers Lincoln's claim practices, its denial patterns, and two recent federal appellate decisions that went against Lincoln.
What Did the Courts Say About Liberty Life Disability Denials?
The most cited decision naming this insurer is Denmark v. Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston, 566 F.3d 1, decided by the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit in 2009.
Denmark came shortly after the Supreme Court's decision in Metropolitan Life Insurance Co. v. Glenn, which held that an insurer deciding claims it also pays from its own funds operates under a conflict of interest that a court must weigh. In Denmark, the First Circuit abandoned its earlier reasoning, which had discounted that conflict on the theory that market forces would keep insurers honest, and held that the conflict must be given weight in reviewing a denial. The court also addressed discovery, holding that a claimant may obtain discovery into the conflict, though such discovery should be narrowly tailored.
Denmark establishes what a court may look at beyond the four corners of the denial letter: how the insurer structured its decision-making, what steps it took to reduce bias, and whether those steps were real.
One caution, because it comes up. There is a well known Supreme Court case called Gobeille v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Co., decided in 2016. It has nothing to do with disability claims. It concerned whether a Vermont law requiring health plans to report claims data to a state database was preempted by ERISA. It is not authority about how Liberty handled disability claims, and you should be skeptical of any page that presents it as if it were.
Sources: Denmark v. Liberty Life Assurance Co. of Boston (1st Cir.); Metropolitan Life Ins. Co. v. Glenn, 554 U.S. 105 (2008).
Has a Court Ordered Liberty to Pay Benefits It Denied?
Yes. In Donachie v. Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston, 745 F.3d 41, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit affirmed summary judgment for the claimant on his claim for long term disability benefits, and returned the case to the district court only with directions to award him attorney's fees.
The claimant had undergone an aortic valve replacement. He could hear and feel the prosthetic valve compressing, which produced diagnosed anxiety and major depression that kept him from his occupation. The court found that Liberty had ignored substantial evidence from his treating physicians that he could not perform his occupation and had produced no reliable evidence to the contrary. Liberty's consulting psychiatrist had worked from the file alone and never spoke with either treating physician, despite a recommendation that the claimant be evaluated by psychology experts.
One qualification, because precision matters. The benefits award covered the own occupation period. Eligibility under the any occupation standard went back for further proceedings.

How Do Liberty Life Policies Define Disability?
Most of these group policies use a two stage definition.
For an initial period, commonly 24 months, you are disabled if you cannot perform the material and substantial duties of your own occupation. After that, the standard usually shifts to whether you can perform any occupation for which you are reasonably qualified by education, training, and experience.
Many of these policies are written around earnings, so that you are disabled if you are unable to earn more than a stated percentage of your prior income. You should also expect a pre-existing condition provision, a 24 month limitation for mental health conditions, offsets that reduce your monthly benefit by Social Security disability and other income, and a requirement that you apply for Social Security disability benefits.
Because these policies were written years ago, the certificate you were given when you enrolled is the document that governs. If you no longer have it, request it in writing from your plan administrator along with the summary plan description. Our article on how disability policies define disability explains what to look for.
Why Are Liberty Life and Lincoln Disability Claims Denied?
The reasons are the same ones that appear across the industry, and they show up in these claims in a predictable order.
Lack of objective evidence. The insurer takes the position that the records do not contain objective findings supporting the restrictions your physician describes. This falls hardest on conditions that do not appear on imaging.
File review by a physician who never examined you. A reviewer reads the file, sometimes an incomplete one, and concludes the records do not support the reported limitations.
The change in definition at 24 months. Benefits paid for two years stop because the standard changed, not because your condition improved. Expect a vocational analysis identifying occupations the insurer says you could perform.
Mental health and self-reported symptom limitations. Where the policy caps benefits for these conditions, how your claim is characterized does most of the work.
Surveillance and social media review. Short clips of ordinary activity are used to argue you are more capable than you reported.
Gaps in treatment. Reduced care is read as improvement, whatever the actual reason was.
Lack of Objective Evidence
The most common reason a Liberty Life or Lincoln claim is denied is that the insurer says your file lacks objective evidence of impairment. This is a particular problem if your condition does not produce findings on imaging or bloodwork. Fibromyalgia, migraine, chronic fatigue syndrome, long COVID, and most psychiatric conditions are diagnosed clinically, by a physician who evaluates reported symptoms against diagnostic criteria, not by a test that returns a number.
Read your certificate before you accept this reasoning. Most group policies require proof that you are disabled; they do not require that the proof be objective, and they rarely define the term at all. When an insurer imposes an objective evidence requirement the policy does not contain, that is an argument to make in your appeal rather than a standard to try to meet.
The Change in Definition at 24 Months
Most Liberty Life group certificates pay benefits for the first 24 months if you cannot perform the material and substantial duties of your own occupation. After 24 months, the standard usually changes: you must be unable to perform the duties of any occupation for which you are reasonably qualified.
Terminations cluster at that 24-month mark, and they often arrive with no change in your medical condition at all. What changed is the test. If your benefits were terminated at or near 24 months, the question is no longer only whether you can do your old job. It is whether there is other work you can actually perform and sustain, which is a vocational question as much as a medical one.
Paper Review by a Physician Who Never Examined You
Lincoln routinely sends claim files to physicians who review records and never meet you. Those reviewers reach a conclusion from paper, and that conclusion is then used to overturn the opinion of the doctor who has treated you for years.
A reviewing physician's opinion is not automatically worth less than your treating doctor's. But a reviewer who never addresses your treating physician's findings, who overlooks test results in the file, or who offers a conclusion outside their own specialty is vulnerable on appeal. Name the reviewer, identify what they did not engage with, and put the omission in the record.
Gaps in Treatment
Insurers read gaps in treatment as evidence that you recovered. Often the real explanation is that you could not afford care, you lost coverage, you could not get an appointment, or there was no further treatment to try.
If your records contain a gap, explain it in writing and support the explanation. An unexplained gap is read against you. An explained one usually is not.
Mental Health and Self-Reported Symptom Limitations
Many Liberty Life certificates cap benefits for mental health conditions at 24 months, and some apply a similar cap to conditions the policy calls self-reported.
Watch how your condition has been classified. A physical condition that happens to be diagnosed clinically is not a self-reported condition, and a physical impairment accompanied by depression is not a mental health claim. Misclassification shortens your benefit period by years, and it is worth challenging as soon as you see it.
Surveillance and Social Media Review
Expect your claim to be investigated. Insurers hire investigators, and they review anything publicly visible on social media.
A photograph of you at a family event does not establish that you can work a full week, and a single good day is not a baseline. But a photograph is concrete in a way that a symptom description is not, and it will be used that way. Assume anything public will be seen, and assume it will be read in the least favorable light available.
How Long Do You Have to Appeal a Denial?
If your policy is governed by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act ("ERISA"), you generally have at least 180 days from the adverse determination to file your appeal. Your denial letter states the deadline that applies to you, and it controls.
If you lost time trying to reach the wrong company, that time still counts against you. This is the practical reason the corporate history on this page matters. Our guide on drafting an effective appeal letter sets out what has to happen inside that window, and why your appeal is your only chance to build the record explains why the evidence you submit during the appeal is usually all a court will ever see.
What Should You Submit to Lincoln With Your Claim or Appeal?
An ERISA appeal is usually your last chance to add anything to the record. A court reviewing the denial later will generally look at what was in front of the insurer when it made its final decision, not at evidence you gather afterwards. That makes the appeal the most important document in your claim.
What belongs in it:
The complete policy and certificate, plus the summary plan description. Request them in writing from the plan administrator if you do not have them. You cannot argue about a standard you have not read.
The full claim file. You are entitled to it. It will contain the reviewer reports, internal notes, and vocational analyses the insurer relied on, and you cannot rebut reasoning you have not seen.
A narrative from your treating physician that addresses the policy language. Not a note saying you are disabled. A statement tying specific findings to the specific duties you cannot perform, and to the definition that actually applies to you.
Objective testing where it exists. Functional capacity evaluations, neuropsychological testing, imaging, pulmonary or cardiac studies. Where it does not exist, say so and explain why.
A vocational report. Particularly after the 24-month change in definition, addressing whether the occupations the insurer identified are ones you could realistically perform and sustain.
Evidence of how you actually function. Daily activity logs, and statements from people who see you: family, former colleagues, a supervisor who watched your performance decline.
A direct response to the insurer's reviewer. Address what they concluded and what they failed to consider, by name.
Frequently Asked Questions About Liberty Mutual Disability Claims

Does Liberty Mutual still handle long term disability claims?
No. Liberty Mutual sold its entire group benefits business, including group long term disability, to Lincoln Financial on May 1, 2018. Liberty Mutual is now a property and casualty insurer writing auto, home, commercial, and workers' compensation coverage. It does not sell or administer group disability insurance.
My disability policy says Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston. Who insures it now?
The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company, or Lincoln Life & Annuity Company of New York for New York policies. Liberty Life was acquired by Lincoln in 2018, renamed Lincoln Life Assurance Company of Boston in 2019, and merged into The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company in 2021. Your policy terms did not change.
Who do I send my disability appeal to?
Send it to the address stated in your denial letter, and direct it to the Lincoln entity identified there. Sending an appeal to Liberty Mutual will not preserve your rights, and your appeal deadline continues to run in the meantime. If your denial letter is unclear about the entity, request your claim file and your certificate in writing.
Did my Liberty Life policy change when Lincoln bought the company?
No. The policy terms, the definition of disability, the limitations, the offsets, and your appeal rights are unchanged. Policyholders received an endorsement at the time of the 2021 merger confirming that all other terms and benefits of the policy remained the same. The insurer's name changed; the contract did not.
I have a Liberty Mutual claim after a work injury. Is that the same thing?
No. Liberty Mutual remains a major workers' compensation insurer, and a workers' compensation claim is a different type of claim with a different process, different standards, and different deadlines. It is possible to have both a workers' compensation claim with Liberty Mutual and a long term disability claim with a different insurer at the same time.
What is Denmark v. Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston?
Denmark is a 2009 First Circuit decision holding that where an insurer both decides claims and pays them from its own funds, that conflict of interest must be given weight when a court reviews a denial. It also permits limited discovery into the conflict. It followed the Supreme Court's decision in Metropolitan Life Insurance Co. v. Glenn.
Can I still sue over a Liberty Life disability denial?
Yes, generally after completing the administrative appeal your plan requires, and subject to the deadline for filing suit stated in your policy. The lawsuit is brought against the current insurer, The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company, which assumed Liberty Life's obligations in the 2021 merger.
Why does my paperwork use three different company names?
Because the company was sold and then renamed twice. Your original certificate says Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston. Correspondence from 2019 to 2021 may say Lincoln Life Assurance Company of Boston. Current correspondence says Lincoln or The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company. All three refer to the same continuous obligation.
What should I do first after a denial?
Request your complete claim file in writing. Under the ERISA claims regulation you are entitled to it free of charge. It will show which records the reviewing physician received, whether that reviewer contacted your doctors, what vocational analysis was performed, and what internal guidelines were applied to your claim.
Should I appeal a Lincoln denial myself or hire a lawyer?
You are allowed to appeal on your own, and some people do it successfully. What makes it risky is that the record closes. If your appeal is denied and you end up in federal court, you will usually be arguing from the file you built, and evidence you left out cannot be added later. Read the list above of what the appeal should contain, then decide whether you can assemble all of it within the deadline.
How Can The Maddox Firm Help With Your Liberty or Lincoln Claim or Appeal?

The Maddox Firm handles long term disability claims on legacy Liberty Life policies the same way we handle any other Lincoln claim, and the corporate history rarely turns out to be the hard part. The hard part is the record.
We have handled a substantial number of these claims and obtained approvals for clients at both the claim and appeal stages, in matters involving a broad range of medical conditions.
Here's how The Maddox Firm can help you with your claim:
We Determine Who Actually Insures Your Policy: We identify the correct entity from your certificate and denial letter, so your appeal and any lawsuit go to the right company the first time and your deadline is not wasted.
We Obtain and Review Your Entire Claim File: We request your complete file and review all of it, including internal claim notes, the reports and credentials of the physicians used, vocational analyses, and any surveillance.
We Find the Governing Policy Language: Legacy policies are often decades old, and claimants frequently no longer have their certificate. We obtain the governing documents rather than working from the insurer's description of them.
We Identify What Your Record Is Missing: We compare the evidence in your file against what your policy requires you to prove, then determine what medical, functional, and vocational evidence must be added before your appeal window closes.
We Work With Your Doctors and Retained Experts: We coordinate with your treating physicians for detailed reports on your restrictions and limitations, and where appropriate arrange functional capacity evaluations and vocational assessments.
We Respond Directly to the Insurer's Reviewers: We answer the file reviewers and examining physicians the insurer relied on, documenting the records they never received and the conclusions their own reports do not support.
We Handle Appeals and Litigation: If your appeal is denied, we are prepared to litigate in federal court on the record we built.
A long term disability claim can be a complicated process, and an incomplete record is a problem that usually cannot be fixed later. If you need help during the claims process, with appealing a claim denial, or with litigating a final adverse long term disability decision, The Maddox Firm can help. The experienced team at The Maddox Firm will examine your insurance policy, correspondence from your insurance company, medical records, and any other relevant documentation in order to give you personalized guidance on how we can help you win your long term disability claim. Our New Jersey and New York long term disability attorneys help clients nationwide.



