top of page
The Maddox Firm Long Term Disability/ERISA Logo

Lincoln Financial Long Term Disability Claims, Denials, and Appeals

9 minutes ago
12 min read
Lincoln National Corporation sign in Fort Wayne, Indiana, Lincoln Financial long term disability claims

If Lincoln Financial denied your long term disability claim, or terminated benefits it had been paying, The Maddox Firm can help you appeal that decision the right way. If you have already appealed and received a final denial, we can handle your litigation.


Lincoln is one of the largest group disability insurers in the country, and a large share of the claims it handles began life as Liberty Mutual policies. If your certificate says Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston and your denial letter says Lincoln, nothing has gone wrong. That is the expected result of a corporate transaction, and it is worth understanding before you appeal.


In this article, we'll discuss which company insures your claim today, how Lincoln policies define disability, why Lincoln denies claims, two recent federal appellate decisions involving Lincoln that matter to claimants, and what you should submit on appeal.


The Maddox Firm has extensive experience with Lincoln claims, including claims on policies originally issued by Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston. We have obtained approvals for clients at the initial claim stage and on appeal, in matters involving a wide range of medical conditions.


Who Insures Your Lincoln Long Term Disability Policy?


The answer today is The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company, based in Fort Wayne, Indiana, or Lincoln Life & Annuity Company of New York for New York policies. Getting there took three steps, and each one shows up on claimants' paperwork.


May 1, 2018. Lincoln completed its acquisition of Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston from Liberty Mutual. The transaction is often reported as $3.3 billion, which is the gross amount paid to Liberty Mutual. Lincoln's net investment in the group benefits business itself was approximately $1.4 billion, consisting of a $1.021 billion purchase price plus $425 million of required capital. The remainder was excess capital held inside the acquired company, the amount Protective Life paid for the separately reinsured individual life and annuity block, and tax items.


September 1, 2019. Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston was renamed Lincoln Life Assurance Company of Boston. Nothing about the company or its policies changed.


October 1, 2021. Lincoln Life Assurance Company of Boston merged into The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company, which assumed all of its obligations. The company's state of domicile moved from New Hampshire to Indiana. Policyholders received an endorsement confirming that all other terms and benefits of the policy remained unchanged.


The practical consequences for you:


  • Your policy terms did not change. The definition of disability, the limitations, the offsets, and your appeal rights are whatever your certificate says they are.

  • Lincoln Life Assurance Company of Boston no longer exists. Any appeal or lawsuit should be directed at the surviving entity, not the dissolved one. This is a live problem, because a great deal of published material still describes Lincoln Life Assurance Company of Boston as the current insurer.

  • Liberty Mutual has no role in your disability claim. Liberty Mutual sold this entire business and no longer writes group disability. If you have a Liberty Mutual claim of some other kind, most commonly workers' compensation, that is a separate matter with a different company. Our page on Liberty Mutual long term disability claims covers this in more detail.


What Have Federal Courts Recently Said About Lincoln Disability Denials?


In 2022 two federal appeals courts ruled against Lincoln, and both decisions changed how a court looks at one of its denials.


The insurer cannot invent new reasons later


In Collier v. Lincoln Life Assurance Company of Boston, decided by the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit on November 21, 2022, the court held that when a district court reviews an ERISA benefit denial de novo, it must evaluate only the reasons the insurer actually gave during the claims process. Lincoln had denied the claim on one basis and then, in litigation, defended it on grounds it had never raised in its denial letters. The Ninth Circuit rejected that approach.


Denial letters are often vague, and insurers frequently develop a more sophisticated theory once a lawyer is involved. Under Collier, in that circuit, the reasons stated in your denial letters are the reasons the insurer is stuck with.


On de novo review, the record may not be closed


In Harris v. Lincoln National Life Insurance Company, decided by the United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit on July 29, 2022, the court held that where review is de novo, the district court is not strictly confined to the administrative record, and the parties may introduce evidence beyond it. The court declined to adopt the "good cause" gatekeeping test used in some other circuits.


That is a genuine exception to the general rule, and it is worth understanding precisely what it does and does not mean. It applies where review is de novo rather than deferential, and it reflects the law of one circuit. It does not make the administrative record unimportant. Building the strongest possible record during your appeal remains the correct approach everywhere, because in most cases, in most courts, that record is all a judge will ever see.



Has a Court Ordered Lincoln to Pay Benefits It Denied?


Yes. In Berg v. The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company, No. 2:24-cv-00097 (E.D. Wash. Jan. 21, 2025), the court entered judgment for the claimant and held her entitled to full retroactive benefits rather than returning the claim to Lincoln for another decision.


The claimant had complications from hand surgery, including complex regional pain syndrome and progressive neuropathy, and was limited to roughly twenty minutes of use of her right hand followed by long breaks. Reviewing the denial without deference, the court found that Lincoln had said it considered her Social Security award and called it not determinative without ever explaining why it disagreed with the administrative law judge's findings; that its retained reviewers had not read the whole file, with one never reviewing the treating physician's questionnaire at all; that one reviewer recorded restrictions inconsistent with full time work and then recommended a full time return to work; and that the denial letters failed to give specific reasons or to address the treating physician's opinions.


This is a district court decision from another circuit, so it does not bind a court here. Its value is as a description of the kind of record that produces an award of benefits rather than a remand.



How Does Lincoln Define Disability?


Most Lincoln group long term disability policies use a two stage definition.


For an initial period, commonly 24 months, you are disabled if you cannot perform the material and substantial duties of your own occupation. After that, the standard usually shifts to whether you can perform any occupation for which you are reasonably qualified by education, training, and experience.


Many of these policies define disability partly in terms of earnings, so that you are disabled if you are unable to earn more than a stated percentage of your prior income. That formulation can support a claim even where you are still working in some reduced capacity.


Expect to find as well:


  • A pre-existing condition provision limiting coverage for conditions treated during a look-back period before coverage began

  • A 24 month limitation for mental health conditions, and in many policies for conditions supported primarily by self-reported symptoms

  • Offsets reducing your monthly benefit by Social Security disability, workers' compensation, state disability, and other income

  • A requirement that you apply for Social Security disability benefits


Our article on how disability policies define disability explains these terms in more detail.


Inside the courthouse where Lincoln Financial long term disability claims are litigated

Why Does Lincoln Deny Long Term Disability Claims?


Lack of Objective Evidence


Lincoln commonly takes the position that the records lack objective findings supporting the restrictions your physician describes. This falls hardest on conditions that do not appear on imaging, including fibromyalgia, chronic fatigue syndrome, migraine, long COVID, autoimmune conditions, and mental health conditions.


The response is to supply the objective evidence that does exist, including functional capacity testing, neuropsychological testing, cardiopulmonary exercise testing, and laboratory findings, and to have your treating physician connect those findings to specific functional limits rather than to a diagnosis.


Paper Review by a Physician Who Never Examined You


Lincoln relies heavily on file reviews by physicians who never meet the claimant. On appeal it is worth establishing whether the reviewer received your complete records, whether the reviewer made any attempt to contact your treating providers, and whether the reviewer's stated conclusions are actually supported by the findings in the reviewer's own report.


The Change in Definition at 24 Months


A large share of Lincoln terminations happen at this transition. Benefits paid for two years stop, not because your condition improved, but because the standard changed. Lincoln will typically obtain a vocational assessment identifying occupations it says you could perform. Rebutting it requires vocational evidence of your own, addressed to your actual restrictions.


Mental Health and Self-Reported Symptom Limitations


Where a policy caps benefits at 24 months for mental health conditions, Lincoln may characterize a claim as primarily psychiatric even where physical conditions are also disabling. Where the policy limits conditions supported primarily by self-reported symptoms, the characterization of your condition decides the outcome. Both are worth contesting directly rather than accepting.


Surveillance and Social Media Review


Lincoln conducts surveillance and reviews social media. Brief footage of ordinary activity gets used to argue you are more capable than reported, even where it shows nothing about whether you could sustain that activity across a full workday.


Gaps in Treatment


Reduced or interrupted treatment is read as improvement. Claimants often reduce care because it stopped helping, because of cost, or because of side effects. Lincoln will not assume the benign explanation, so your record should supply it.


What Should You Submit to Lincoln With Your Claim or Appeal?


Your appeal is the evidentiary record of your case. For an ERISA claim it is usually the last chance to add anything a court will see. Depending on your claim, it may need:


  • Complete medical records from every treating provider, including records Lincoln never requested

  • A detailed narrative report from your treating physician describing specific restrictions and limitations

  • Objective testing where available and appropriate to your condition

  • A functional capacity evaluation documenting what you can sustain across a full workday

  • A vocational assessment addressing your own occupation, or the any occupation standard after the transition

  • Your complete Social Security file, including the ALJ decision, where you have an award

  • A point-by-point response to Lincoln's reviewing physician, identifying records they never received and findings they mischaracterized

  • Statements from family, friends, and coworkers describing observed decline

  • Documentation of medication side effects affecting stamina, concentration, and reliability


For why this stage carries so much weight, see why your appeal is your only chance to build the record.


How Long Do You Have to Appeal a Lincoln Denial?


If your policy is governed by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act ("ERISA"), you generally have at least 180 days from the adverse determination to file your appeal. Your denial letter states the deadline that applies to you, and it controls.


That window is shorter than it sounds once you account for requesting the claim file, gathering updated records, scheduling functional and vocational testing, and giving your physician time to write a substantive report. Missing it usually costs the right to sue at all. Our guide on drafting an effective appeal letter sets out the sequence.


APPEAL spelled in wooden letters on a desk, Lincoln Financial long term disability appeal

Frequently Asked Questions About Lincoln Disability Claims


Why did Lincoln Financial deny my long term disability claim?


Lincoln most often denies claims for lack of objective medical evidence, based on a file review by a physician who never examined you, or at the 24 month mark when the policy definition changes from your own occupation to any occupation. Your denial letter states Lincoln's reasons, and your claim file shows what it actually relied on.


My policy says Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston. Who do I deal with now?


Lincoln. Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston was acquired by Lincoln on May 1, 2018, renamed Lincoln Life Assurance Company of Boston on September 1, 2019, and merged into The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company on October 1, 2021. Your policy terms did not change. Liberty Mutual has no role in your disability claim.


Which Lincoln entity should be named in an appeal or lawsuit?


Generally The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company, or Lincoln Life & Annuity Company of New York for New York policies. Lincoln Life Assurance Company of Boston no longer exists as a separate company. Confirm the entity identified on your certificate and denial letter, because naming the wrong company can create avoidable problems.


What is the Collier v. Lincoln Life case?


Collier v. Lincoln Life Assurance Company of Boston is a 2022 Ninth Circuit decision holding that on de novo review of an ERISA benefit denial, a court considers only the reasons the insurer gave during the claims process. Lincoln could not defend the denial in court on grounds it never raised in its denial letters.


Why did Lincoln stop paying my benefits after two years?


Most Lincoln group policies change the definition of disability after 24 months. For the first two years you need only be unable to perform your own occupation. After that you generally must be unable to perform any occupation you are reasonably suited for. Many terminations happen at this transition rather than because of medical improvement.


Can I sue Lincoln for denying my disability claim?


Yes, but generally only after completing the administrative appeal your plan requires. For ERISA-governed claims a court will usually review only the evidence in the administrative record compiled during that appeal, which is why the appeal is where the case is actually built. Your policy also sets a deadline for filing suit.


Does Lincoln use surveillance on disability claimants?


Yes. Lincoln conducts surveillance and reviews publicly available social media. Footage of brief, ordinary activity is often used to argue a claimant is more functional than reported, even though it shows nothing about whether that activity could be sustained across a full workday, week after week.


What should I do first after Lincoln denies my claim?


Request your complete claim file in writing. Under the ERISA claims regulation you are entitled to it free of charge. It will show which records Lincoln's reviewing physician received, whether that reviewer contacted your doctors, what vocational analysis was performed, and what internal guidelines Lincoln applied.


Does Lincoln have to show me new evidence before denying my appeal?


Yes, for ERISA disability claims. If Lincoln generates or obtains new evidence or relies on a new rationale while your appeal is pending, it must provide that material before issuing a final denial and give you a reasonable opportunity to respond.


Should I appeal a Lincoln denial myself or hire a lawyer?


You may appeal on your own, but for an ERISA claim the appeal is usually the last opportunity to put evidence into the record a court will review. Evidence not submitted during the appeal is generally excluded from litigation, which makes this the stage where representation matters most.


How Can The Maddox Firm Help With Your Lincoln Claim or Appeal?


The Maddox Firm office entrance, Lincoln Financial long term disability attorneys

The Maddox Firm treats your Lincoln appeal as the most important stage of your case, because in most long term disability claims it is. We prepare every appeal as though it is the last evidence a court will ever see.


We handle Lincoln and legacy Liberty claims regularly, and we have obtained approvals for clients on initial claims and on appeal, across a broad range of medical conditions.


Here's how The Maddox Firm can help you with your Lincoln claim:


  • We Confirm Which Entity Insures Your Claim: Policies originally issued by Liberty Life Assurance Company of Boston are now obligations of The Lincoln National Life Insurance Company. We make sure your appeal and any lawsuit are directed at the right company.

  • We Obtain and Review Your Entire Lincoln Claim File: We request your complete file and review all of it, including internal claim notes, the reports and credentials of the physicians Lincoln used, vocational analyses, and any surveillance. This shows us what Lincoln relied on, what it left out, and where its reasoning is vulnerable.

  • We Hold Lincoln to the Reasons It Gave: We document precisely what Lincoln stated in each denial letter, so that the case is decided on the rationale Lincoln actually used rather than one developed later.

  • We Identify What Your Record Is Missing: We compare the evidence in your file against what your policy requires you to prove, then determine what medical, functional, and vocational evidence must be added before your appeal window closes.

  • We Work With Your Doctors and Retained Experts: We coordinate with your treating physicians for detailed reports on your restrictions and limitations, and where appropriate arrange functional capacity evaluations and vocational assessments.

  • We Respond Directly to Lincoln's Reviewers: We answer the file reviewers and examining physicians Lincoln relied on, documenting the records they never received and the conclusions their own reports do not support.

  • We Handle Appeals and Litigation: If your appeal is denied, we are prepared to litigate in federal court on the record we built.


A Lincoln long term disability claim can be a complicated process, and an incomplete record is a problem that usually cannot be fixed later. If you need help during the claims process, with appealing a claim denial, or with litigating a final adverse long term disability decision, The Maddox Firm can help. The experienced team at The Maddox Firm will examine your insurance policy, correspondence from your insurance company, medical records, and any other relevant documentation in order to give you personalized guidance on how we can help you win your long term disability claim. Our New Jersey and New York long term disability attorneys help clients nationwide.


bottom of page