maddoxfirm
top of page

What Teachers Should Know About Long Term Disability Insurance

Schoolbus - What Teachers Should Know About Long Term Disability Insurance

Understanding the complexities of long term disability (“LTD”) insurance is crucial for teachers, who are exposed to unique occupational risks ranging from physical strains like repetitive stress to mental health issues due to high stress levels.  In this article, we’ll explain how LTD insurance works, its importance for educators, and outline how to effectively manage the disability claims process.  From comprehending policy nuances to proving a disability and handling income offsets, this article equips you with the necessary knowledge to secure your financial stability and increase your chances of a successful claim.

 

Why Do Teachers Need Long Term Disability Insurance?


As a teacher, you face unique occupational risks that can impact your ability to work, ranging from physical injuries like repetitive stress from writing on the board, to vocal strain from daily speaking, and even mental health issues due to high stress levels.  Long term disability (“LTD”) insurance is designed to provide you with a safety net by replacing a portion of your salary if you become unable to work due to a disability, whether it’s due to an illness, injury, or a mental health condition.


The basic concept of LTD insurance is to ensure that if you find yourself disabled and unable to continue teaching or performing your job duties over a long period, you are not left without financial support.  Typically, LTD insurance will cover anywhere from 50% to 70% of your pre-disability earnings.  These benefits start after an initial waiting period, which can vary from several weeks to several months depending on your policy, and can last until you are able to return to work, reach retirement age, or for a set period described in the policy.


For teachers, this type of insurance is especially important.  Not only does it provide financial stability in the case of severe health issues, but it also ensures that you can focus on your recovery without the added stress of financial hardship.  LTD insurance allows you to maintain your standard of living and secure essential needs like housing, groceries, and medical care, which might otherwise be overwhelming on a reduced or nonexistent salary. This makes LTD insurance a critical component of your financial planning, offering you peace of mind knowing that you’re protected against the financial impacts of a long-term disability.

 

How Does LTD Insurance Differ from Other Types of Disability Insurance?


long term disability insurance piggybank for teachers

Long term disability (“LTD”) insurance is designed to provide financial support for extended periods when you are unable to work due to a disability.  It differs significantly from other types of disability insurance and benefits, such as short term disability insurance and workers’ compensation, in several key ways:


  • Duration of Benefits: The most significant difference lies in the duration for which benefits are paid.  Short term disability (“STD”) insurance typically covers a period from a few weeks up to one year, depending on the policy.  In contrast, LTD insurance kicks in after short term benefits end (if you have them) and can continue providing benefits for several years—the length of your disability, until you retire, or when the policy term expires, whichever comes first.

  • Scope of Coverage: LTD insurance covers disabilities that might not be work-related, providing a broader safety net.  It is not limited to injuries or illnesses incurred on the job, unlike workers’ compensation, which only covers work-related injuries and illnesses.  Workers’ compensation also offers additional benefits like covering medical expenses and providing compensation for permanent injuries, which LTD insurance does not cover.

  • Benefit Amount: LTD insurance typically replaces 50% to 70% of your salary, and you usually have the option to buy a policy that could cover more at a higher premium.  STD insurance also covers a similar percentage of your salary but is usually capped at a shorter duration.  Workers’ compensation benefits are calculated based on a percentage of your average earnings and the nature and severity of your disability, potentially leading to different benefit amounts.

  • Eligibility Requirements: To receive LTD benefits, you must meet the specific definition of disability as outlined in your LTD policy, which often includes being unable to perform the duties of your own occupation.  STD insurance generally has similar eligibility criteria but is intended for less severe disabilities.  Workers’ compensation requires that the injury or illness be directly related to your job.

  • Cost and Funding: LTD and STD insurance premiums can be paid by either you or your employer, and they might be offered as part of your employment benefits package.  Workers’ compensation is paid entirely by the employer and is a mandatory coverage that employers must provide.


Understanding these differences can help you as a teacher determine the type and extent of coverage you need to adequately protect yourself against the financial implications of potential disabilities.  This ensures that in the event of a serious illness or injury, you have sufficient coverage to maintain your financial stability.

 

How Do LTD Policies Typically Define Disability for Teachers?


job description: LTD means disability from your occupation

In long term disability (“LTD”) insurance policies, the definition of “disability” plays a crucial role in determining your eligibility for benefits.  This definition can vary significantly between policies, but generally, they relate to your ability to perform the duties of your job as a teacher.  Understanding how disability is defined is essential to knowing when and how you can access your benefits.


Common definitions of disability in LTD policies include:


  • Own Occupation: Under this definition, you are considered disabled if you are unable to perform the material duties of your specific job as a teacher.  This would include tasks like standing for long periods to deliver lessons, speaking clearly to communicate with students, and maintaining the cognitive engagement required for planning lessons and assessing student work.  If a medical condition—be it physical or mental—prevents you from performing these tasks effectively, you would likely qualify for LTD benefits under an “own occupation” definition.

  • Any Occupation: In contrast, the “any occupation” definition is broader and more stringent.  Under this definition, to be considered disabled, you must be unable to perform the duties of any occupation for which you are qualified by education, training, or experience.  This means that even if you are unable to continue teaching, you might not qualify for benefits if you could still perform another job role, such as a desk job that might be less demanding physically but still utilizes your skills and training.

  • Hybrid Definitions: Some policies use a hybrid definition that combines elements of both “own occupation” and “any occupation.”  These policies may provide benefits under the “own occupation” definition for a limited period (e.g., the first 24 months of disability) before switching to the “any occupation” definition.  This shift means that initially, your inability to perform your teaching duties could qualify you for benefits, but to continue receiving benefits after the initial period, you would need to demonstrate an inability to perform any job reasonably suited to your qualifications.


As a teacher, these definitions impact your long term disability insurance coverage significantly.  If you develop a condition that impairs your ability to stand, speak, or engage cognitively, the specific definition of disability in your policy will determine your benefit eligibility.  For example, vocal cord issues might not prevent you from working in another profession that requires less speaking, affecting your eligibility under an “any occupation” or hybrid policy after the initial own occupation period.


When choosing an LTD policy or evaluating your existing coverage, it’s crucial to understand which definition of disability it uses and consider how that definition aligns with your unique risks and career trajectory as a teacher.  This understanding can help you plan for financial security, knowing how you’re protected in the event of a disability.

 

How Do I Prove Disability to My Insurance Company as a Teacher?


To prove disability to your insurance company as a teacher, you must demonstrate to your insurance company that you are unable to perform the demands of your occupation due to your condition and symptoms.  This process involves detailing the specific requirements of your job and presenting medical evidence that links your health condition to your inability to meet these demands.


As a teacher, your job involves several key duties that can be physically and mentally demanding.  Common job functions include:


  • Standing and Moving Around: Frequently required to stand for long periods while teaching, moving around the classroom, or supervising students.

  • Speaking: Continuous communication through lecturing and interacting with students, staff, and parents, which demands vocal endurance.

  • Cognitive Engagement: Planning lessons, grading, managing classroom activities, and maintaining high levels of concentration and emotional intelligence to address student needs effectively.


Various conditions and symptoms can hinder your ability to perform these duties, including:


  • Musculoskeletal Disorders: Such as back pain or joint injuries, which can make standing and moving painful or impossible.

  • Vocal Disorders: Including vocal cord nodules or chronic laryngitis, which can severely impact your ability to speak clearly.

  • Mental Health Issues: Such as severe anxiety or depression, which can impair cognitive functions, decision-making, and the emotional stamina required to manage a classroom.

  • Neurological Disorders: Like multiple sclerosis or Parkinson’s disease, which could affect both physical movements and cognitive functions.


To substantiate your LTD claim, you will need to provide comprehensive medical evidence that documents your condition and its impact on your ability to perform your job functions.


medical evidence of long term disability yellow binder

Common types of medical evidence include:


  • Medical Records: Comprehensive documentation from your healthcare providers, including diagnosis, treatment records, and notes on how your condition impacts your daily functions.

  • Physician’s Statements: Detailed statements from your doctors that specifically describe how your medical conditions prevent you from performing your teaching duties. An attending physician statement is an especially crucial piece of evidence for your claim.

  • Specialist Evaluations: Reports from specialists relevant to your condition, such as orthopedists, psychiatrists, or neurologists, providing expert insights into how your symptoms affect your job capabilities.

  • Functional Capacity Evaluation (“FCE”): An assessment performed by a physical therapist or other rehabilitation specialist that quantitatively measures your physical abilities in various domains, such as lifting, walking, and sitting, which can help illustrate the physical limitations you face.

  • Personal Testimony: A personal statement detailing your daily struggles and how your condition affects your professional responsibilities and overall quality of life.


To successfully prove disability under your LTD policy, it’s essential that all medical evidence is current and clearly ties your medical condition to your inability to perform specifically as a teacher.  You should work closely with your healthcare providers to ensure that all documentation is thorough and explicitly addresses the demands of your occupation.  This approach will help streamline the claims process and increase the likelihood of your claim being approved by the insurance company.

 

Can I Work While Receiving LTD Benefits?


Yes, you can work while receiving long term disability (“LTD”) benefits, but there are restrictions and specific provisions that govern how much you can work and earn without affecting your benefits.  Understanding these rules is essential to maintaining your LTD benefits while potentially returning to work in a limited capacity.


LTD policies are designed to provide financial support when a disability prevents you from working as you normally would.  However, most policies encourage some form of return to work by incorporating provisions that allow you to work in a limited capacity.  Typically, you can work and still receive LTD benefits as long as your earnings do not exceed a certain percentage of your pre-disability income.  This cap is often around 80%.  If your combined income from your limited work and your LTD benefits exceeds this threshold, your benefits may be reduced or terminated.


To encourage beneficiaries to return to work if they are able, insurers often offer "return to work" incentives.  If you are able to work but earn less than your pre-disability income due to your disability, you may receive partial LTD benefits to make up some of the income difference.  This is particularly relevant for teachers who might return to work part-time or take on less demanding roles within education.  Additionally, some policies include support for rehabilitation, including physical therapy or vocational training, to help you transition back into the workforce.


As a teacher, if you find that you can still perform some of your job duties or take on a different, less demanding role, you can still be eligible for LTD benefits under the right conditions.  Here’s how:


  • Clearly Defined Earnings and Duties: Maintain clear records of your working hours, the nature of your duties, and your earnings.  This documentation will be crucial for your insurance company to determine how your current working arrangement fits within the policy provisions.

  • Ongoing Medical Certification: Continue to provide medical evidence that supports your claim of disability, even if you are working in a limited capacity.  This should include regular updates from your treating physicians about your condition and functional limitations.

  • Communication with Your Insurer: Keep an open line of communication with your insurance provider.  Inform them of any changes in your work status, earnings, or medical condition to avoid any misunderstandings that could affect your benefit status.


Understanding and navigating the conditions of your LTD policy can ensure that you maximize your benefits while exploring your capacity to work.  These provisions are designed to support your recovery and partial return to work, if feasible, while still providing the financial support you need.

 

How Does My Teacher’s Pension Affect My LTD Benefits?


a teacher's pension plan could affect disability benefits

When you’re a teacher receiving long term disability (“LTD”) benefits, additional income sources such as a teacher’s pension can affect the amount of LTD benefits you receive.  This interaction between different income sources is governed by the specific terms of your LTD insurance policy, typically under clauses related to “other income” or “offsets.”


Many LTD policies contain provisions that reduce your monthly LTD benefits paid out by the amount you receive from other income sources, including pensions.  This is commonly referred to as an “offset.”  The rationale behind this is to prevent you from receiving more income while disabled than you would have earned while working.


For example, if your LTD policy is designed to replace 60% of your pre-disability income and you begin to receive a pension that constitutes 40% of your pre-disability income, your LTD insurer may reduce the benefits they pay by the amount of your pension.  Essentially, the total income you would receive from the LTD benefits and the pension should not exceed a certain percentage of your pre-disability earnings.


It is crucial to review your LTD policy details to understand how it handles offsets.  Some policies might offset for private pensions but not for government or state pensions, while others might consider any pension where the employer contributed as an offsetting income.

Understanding the complex interaction between different sources of income during disability can be challenging.  Consulting with an attorney specializing in disability insurance can provide tailored advice based on the specifics of your situation and policy.

 

What Common Reasons Do LTD Claims Get Denied for Teachers?


Long term disability (“LTD”) claims can be denied for a variety of reasons, and understanding these can help you as a teacher to prepare a more robust application and potentially avoid common pitfalls.  Here are some of the most frequent reasons why LTD claims are denied, particularly for teachers:


  • Insufficient Medical Evidence: Lack of detailed and comprehensive medical documentation proving the disability prevents the performance of job-specific tasks.

  • Non-compliance with Treatment: Failure to follow prescribed medical treatments which can lead to questions about the severity of the condition.

  • Definition of Disability Not Met: Your medical condition does not meet your insurance company’s criteria for “disability” under either “own occupation” or “any occupation” definitions.

  • Pre-existing Conditions: The disability is related to a condition that existed prior to the coverage period specified in the LTD policy.

  • Delayed Filing: Not submitting the LTD claim within the time frames stipulated by the insurance policy.

  • Errors in Application: Inaccuracies or incomplete information in the LTD application or supporting documents.

  • Eligibility Issues: You do not meet the basic eligibility requirements outlined in the LTD policy, such as length of time in employment or job status (full-time vs. part-time).

  • Surveillance and Social Media: Insurers might use surveillance tactics or check social media profiles to find evidence that contradicts the claims of disability.


To address these issues, ensure thorough and accurate medical documentation, comply with all treatment plans, understand your policy’s definitions and exclusions, and complete all application forms correctly and timely.  Additionally, it is always recommended that you consult with a long term disability insurance attorney who can bolster your LTD claim and increase your chances of a successful outcome.

 

How Can The Maddox Firm Prove My Short or Long Term Disability Claim?


The Maddox Firm | Long Term Disability & ERISA

The Maddox Firm understands the unique challenges faced by teachers when filing short and long term disability claims.  Our experienced team is dedicated to guiding you through every step of the claims process, ensuring that your rights are protected and your case is presented effectively.


Here are a few ways we can assist you:


  • We Examine Your Policy and Assess Your Claim: We start by thoroughly reviewing your disability insurance policy to understand the specific terms and coverage nuances that apply to your situation.  This includes deciphering the complex language surrounding job-specific duties and benefits calculations for teachers, who often face unique occupational risks and demands.  Our goal is to assess your claim’s strengths and potential challenges, crafting a strategy tailored to your educational role.

  • We Handle All Communications with Your Insurance Company: Dealing with insurance companies can be daunting and time-consuming.  Our team takes on the responsibility of all communications with your insurance company, from initial claim submission, requests for additional documentation or interviews, and settlement discussions.  For teachers, we ensure that the nuances of educational environments and the impact of your disability on your ability to perform classroom and administrative tasks are clearly communicated and understood.

  • We Help You Obtain Evidence to Support Your Claim: Solid evidence is key to a successful disability claim.  We assist you in gathering comprehensive medical documentation that clearly outlines your disability and its impact on your teaching performance.  Additionally, we help compile detailed employment records and other relevant documentation to accurately represent your professional circumstances, crucial for teachers whose ability to perform can be integrally linked to cognitive and physical health.

  • We Handle Appeals and Litigation: If your claim is denied, we are prepared to lead the appeals process.  Our team meticulously prepares your appeal, including assembling a robust evidence package and crafting a compelling argument for why your claim should be approved.  Should it be necessary to escalate to litigation, we have the expertise to represent you effectively in court, ensuring that your case as a teacher is argued persuasively.


The Maddox Firm is committed to delivering comprehensive legal support tailored to the needs of teachers, helping you navigate the complex landscape of disability claims to secure the benefits you deserve.


A short term disability or long term disability claim can be a complicated process for a teacher. If you need help during the claims process, with appealing a claim denial, or with litigating a final adverse short term or long term disability decision, The Maddox Firm can help.  The experienced team at The Maddox Firm will examine your insurance policy, correspondence from your insurance company, medical records, and any other relevant documentation in order to give you personalized guidance on how we can help you win your short and/or long term disability claim. Our New Jersey and New York long term disability attorneys help clients nationwide.

 

 

bottom of page