top of page
The Maddox Firm Long Term Disability/ERISA Logo

Aetna Long Term Disability Claims, Denials, and Appeals

5 minutes ago
12 min read
Denial notice on an envelope, Aetna long term disability claim

If you have a long term disability claim under an Aetna policy and it was denied, or benefits you were receiving were terminated, The Maddox Firm can help you appeal that decision the right way. If you have already appealed and received a final denial, we can handle your litigation.


Aetna claims come with a wrinkle that catches almost everyone. Your certificate names Aetna. Your correspondence comes from The Hartford. Your employer may still call it the Aetna plan. All three can be true at once.


In this article, we'll discuss why that happens and who is actually responsible for your claim, how these policies define disability, why these claims get denied, what a federal appeals court has said about the way Aetna decided a disability claim, and what you should submit on appeal.


The Maddox Firm has extensive experience with claims on Aetna policies, including those now administered by The Hartford. We have obtained approvals for clients at the initial claim stage and on appeal, in matters involving a wide range of medical conditions.


Who Handles Aetna Long Term Disability Claims Now?


The Hartford, in almost all cases.


On October 23, 2017, The Hartford announced an agreement to acquire Aetna's United States group life and disability business for $1.45 billion. The transaction closed on November 1, 2017. Roughly 1,800 Aetna employees moved to The Hartford along with the book of business.


The structure is the part worth understanding. The deal was indemnity reinsurance, not a purchase of Aetna Life Insurance Company and not a transfer of the policies themselves. The Hartford's subsidiary, Hartford Life and Accident Insurance Company, agreed to reinsure the book on an indemnity basis. That means the in-force policies stayed on Aetna paper while The Hartford took over the economics and the day-to-day administration.


A transition letter sent to claimants at the time confirmed that The Hartford became the administrator and reinsurer as of November 1, 2017, that claims moved onto The Hartford's systems within about two weeks, that claim numbers and portal logins stayed the same, and that communications going forward would carry The Hartford's branding.


So, in practice:


  • Your certificate may name Aetna Life Insurance Company as the insurer. That is the company that issued the coverage.

  • Your claim correspondence, denial letters, and appeal address come from The Hartford.

  • Your policy terms did not change. A reinsurance transaction does not rewrite your contract.


Before filing an appeal or a lawsuit, get the governing documents and determine which entity is the correct party. Where a certificate names one company and the denial letter comes from another, that question deserves a real answer rather than a guess. Our page on The Hartford's long term disability claims covers The Hartford's claim practices in detail, and most of it applies directly to an Aetna-issued policy.


Does Aetna Still Sell Long Term Disability Insurance?


Not to new employer groups. Aetna exited the group life and disability business with the 2017 transaction and agreed instead to have its medical sales force sell The Hartford's group life and disability products. Aetna's current employer product line is health plans, pharmacy, dental, vision, supplemental health, and group Medicare. Group long term disability is not on it.


Aetna itself is now part of CVS Health, which completed its acquisition of Aetna on November 28, 2018, in a transaction valued at roughly $70 billion in equity value. That corporate change came after the disability business had already moved to The Hartford, and it does not affect how a legacy Aetna disability claim is handled.


What Have Courts Said About How Aetna Decides Disability Claims?


The most useful decision for claimants is Gaither v. Aetna Life Insurance Co., 394 F.3d 792, decided by the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit in 2004.


The court held that an ERISA fiduciary deciding a claim cannot ignore readily available information. In the court's words, fiduciaries "cannot shut their eyes to readily available information when the evidence in the record suggests that the information might confirm the beneficiary's theory of entitlement and when they have little or no evidence in the record to refute that theory." Denying benefits without making a reasonable inquiry was arbitrary and capricious.


The pattern Gaither describes recurs constantly. The insurer's file has a gap, the gap happens to be exactly where the evidence supporting your claim would be, and the insurer denies the claim on the basis that the record does not establish disability, having never asked for the records that would have. Under Gaither, in that circuit, the failure to ask is itself a problem.


The way to use it is to make the gaps explicit in your appeal: which records were never requested, which treating providers were never contacted, which questions the reviewing physician never asked.


The Aetna case that is not a disability case


You may come across Aetna Health Inc. v. Davila, 542 U.S. 200 (2004), a Supreme Court decision. It is important, and it is regularly misdescribed on legal websites, so it is worth being clear about.


Davila was a health coverage case, not a disability case, and the defendant was an Aetna HMO entity rather than Aetna Life Insurance Company. The Court held that state law claims against a plan for denying coverage are completely preempted by ERISA where the claimant could have sued under ERISA's own enforcement provision.


What Davila confirms is the shape of your remedies. If your claim is governed by ERISA, you generally cannot sue your insurance company for bad faith, and you generally cannot recover punitive damages or damages for emotional distress. What you can recover is the benefits owed under the plan, and in the court's discretion, attorney's fees and interest. The Supreme Court reached the same conclusion for a disability claim decades earlier in Pilot Life Insurance Co. v. Dedeaux, 481 U.S. 41 (1987).


That is a hard thing to learn late. It is also the reason the administrative appeal matters so much: the benefits themselves are the remedy, and the record built during the appeal is what determines whether you get them.



Has a Court Ordered Aetna to Pay Benefits It Denied?


Yes. Dunda v. Aetna Life Insurance Company, No. 6:15-cv-06232 (W.D.N.Y. June 30, 2016), produced three findings that recur in these claims.


The claimant was a store manager with a herniated disc, sciatica, and degenerative disc disease. The court found that Aetna had required objective medical evidence the plan did not call for, and had previously approved her benefits on the same records it later said were insufficient. It found that Aetna had pushed her to apply for Social Security disability, taken the offset benefit of her award, and then failed to meaningfully address the agency's determination. And it found that Aetna had made adverse credibility findings about her reported symptoms while declining to order the examination the plan allowed, resting instead on a review of paper.


On the remedy, the court ordered Aetna to reinstate her monthly benefits and pay what was past due, holding that sending the claim back would be a useless formality because the administrative record was sufficient and no new evidence could support a denial.


That ruling pairs naturally with Gaither. Gaither concerns an insurer failing to gather evidence it should have sought. Dunda concerns an insurer demanding evidence the policy never required.



Legal materials for an Aetna long term disability appeal

How Do Aetna Policies Define Disability?


Most Aetna group long term disability policies use a two stage definition.


For an initial period, commonly 24 months, you are disabled if you cannot perform the material and substantial duties of your own occupation. After that, the standard usually shifts to whether you can perform any reasonable occupation for which you are or may reasonably become qualified by education, training, or experience.


Many of these policies also define disability partly by earnings, using a threshold percentage of your pre-disability income.


Expect to find as well:


  • A pre-existing condition provision limiting coverage for conditions treated during a look-back period before coverage began

  • A 24 month limitation for mental health conditions, and in many policies for conditions supported primarily by self-reported symptoms

  • Offsets reducing your monthly benefit by Social Security disability, workers' compensation, state disability, and other income

  • A requirement that you apply for Social Security disability benefits

  • A contractual deadline for filing suit, separate from your appeal deadline


Because these are older policies, the certificate in effect when you became disabled is what governs. If you no longer have it, request it in writing from your plan administrator along with the summary plan description. Our article on how disability policies define disability explains what to look for.


Why Are Aetna Long Term Disability Claims Denied?


Lack of Objective Evidence


The most common stated reason is that the medical records do not contain objective findings supporting the restrictions your physician describes. This falls hardest on conditions that do not appear on imaging, including fibromyalgia, chronic fatigue syndrome, migraine, long COVID, autoimmune conditions, and mental health conditions.


The response is to supply the objective evidence that does exist, including functional capacity testing, neuropsychological testing, cardiopulmonary exercise testing, and laboratory findings, and to have your treating physician connect those findings to specific functional limits rather than to a diagnosis.


Paper Review by a Physician Who Never Examined You


These claims are frequently denied on a file review by a physician who has never met you. Under Gaither, whether that reviewer had the complete file, and whether anyone tried to obtain the missing pieces, is itself a fair question. Establish it in the appeal rather than arguing only about the reviewer's conclusions.


The Change in Definition at 24 Months


Benefits paid without dispute for two years stop, not because your condition improved, but because the standard changed. Expect a vocational analysis identifying occupations the insurer says you could perform. Rebutting it requires vocational evidence of your own, addressed to your actual restrictions.


Mental Health and Self-Reported Symptom Limitations


Where a policy caps benefits at 24 months for these conditions, how your claim is labeled largely decides it. A claim involving both physical and psychiatric conditions can be recast as primarily psychiatric, which is worth contesting directly.


Surveillance and Social Media Review


Surveillance is common, particularly around the 24 month transition. Short clips of ordinary activity get used to argue you are more capable than you reported, even where the footage says nothing about whether you could sustain that activity through a workday.


Gaps or Reductions in Treatment


Reduced treatment is read as improvement. Claimants often cut back on care because it stopped helping, because of cost, or because of side effects. Your record should explain the reason rather than leaving the insurer to assume the least favorable one.


What Should You Submit With Your Aetna Appeal?


Your appeal is the evidentiary record of your case. In an ERISA claim it is usually the last opportunity to put anything in front of a court. Depending on your claim, it may need:


  • Complete medical records from every treating provider, including records that were never requested

  • A detailed narrative report from your treating physician describing specific restrictions and limitations

  • Objective testing where available and appropriate to your condition

  • A functional capacity evaluation documenting what you can sustain across a full workday

  • A vocational assessment addressed to your own occupation, or to the any occupation standard after the transition

  • Your complete Social Security file, including the ALJ decision, where you have an award

  • A point-by-point response to the reviewing physician, identifying records they never received and findings they mischaracterized

  • Statements from family, friends, and coworkers describing what they have observed

  • Documentation of medication side effects affecting stamina, concentration, and reliability


For why this stage carries so much weight, see why your appeal is your only chance to build the record.


How Long Do You Have to Appeal an Aetna Denial?


If your policy is governed by the Employee Retirement Income Security Act ("ERISA"), you generally have at least 180 days from the adverse determination to file your appeal. Your denial letter states the deadline that applies to you, and it controls.


Your policy also contains its own deadline for filing a lawsuit after your final denial. Those contractual deadlines are enforceable, they are often shorter than people expect, and in many policies the clock starts before the appeal process is finished. Locate that provision in your certificate now rather than after your appeal is decided.


Our guide on drafting an effective appeal letter sets out the sequence.


Frequently Asked Questions About Aetna Disability Claims


Why is The Hartford handling my Aetna disability claim?


The Hartford acquired Aetna's United States group life and disability business through a reinsurance transaction that closed on November 1, 2017. The Hartford became the administrator and reinsurer of the book. Your policy terms did not change, but your claim correspondence, denial letters, and appeal address now come from The Hartford.


Federal courthouse where Aetna long term disability cases are heard

Does Aetna still offer long term disability insurance?


Not to new employer groups. Aetna exited the group life and disability business in 2017 and agreed to sell The Hartford's group products through its medical sales force instead. Aetna's current employer offerings are health, pharmacy, dental, vision, supplemental health, and group Medicare products.


My certificate says Aetna Life Insurance Company. Who do I sue?


That depends on your plan documents, and it is worth resolving before filing. Because the 2017 transaction was indemnity reinsurance, in-force policies remained on Aetna paper while The Hartford administers them. Get your certificate and summary plan description and identify the named insurer and plan administrator rather than assuming.


Why did my Aetna benefits stop after two years?


Most Aetna group policies change the definition of disability after 24 months. For the first two years you need only be unable to perform your own occupation. After that you generally must be unable to perform any reasonable occupation you are or could become qualified for. Many terminations happen at this transition rather than because of medical improvement.


What is the Gaither v. Aetna case?


Gaither v. Aetna Life Insurance Co., 394 F.3d 792 (10th Cir. 2004), holds that a plan fiduciary cannot ignore readily available information that might support the claimant's entitlement to benefits. Denying a claim without making a reasonable inquiry into the missing evidence was arbitrary and capricious.


Can I sue Aetna for bad faith over my disability denial?


Generally not, if your plan is governed by ERISA. In Pilot Life Insurance Co. v. Dedeaux and later in Aetna Health Inc. v. Davila, the Supreme Court held that ERISA preempts state law bad faith claims for improper handling of plan benefits. What you can recover is the benefits owed, plus interest and attorney's fees at the court's discretion.


Did CVS buying Aetna affect my disability claim?


No. CVS Health completed its acquisition of Aetna on November 28, 2018, nearly a year after Aetna's group disability business had already moved to The Hartford. The CVS transaction concerned Aetna's health insurance business and does not change how a legacy Aetna disability claim is handled.


What should I do first after an Aetna disability denial?


Request your complete claim file in writing from the address on your denial letter, and locate the deadline for filing suit in your certificate. Under the ERISA claims regulation the file is yours free of charge. It will show which records the reviewing physician received and whether anyone attempted to obtain the ones that were missing.


Should I appeal an Aetna denial myself or hire a lawyer?


You may appeal on your own, but for an ERISA claim the appeal is usually the last opportunity to put evidence into the record a court will review. Evidence not submitted during the appeal is generally excluded from litigation, which makes this the stage where representation matters most.


How Can The Maddox Firm Help With Your Aetna Claim or Appeal?


The Maddox Firm office entrance, Aetna long term disability attorneys

The Maddox Firm treats your appeal as the most important stage of your case, because in most long term disability claims it is. On Aetna claims we start by establishing who is actually on the other side, because the answer is frequently not what the certificate says.


We handle these claims regularly, whichever name appears on the correspondence, and we have obtained approvals for clients at both the claim and appeal stages across a broad range of medical conditions.


Here's how The Maddox Firm can help you with your Aetna claim:


  • We Determine Which Company Is the Correct Party: Where a certificate names Aetna Life Insurance Company and correspondence comes from The Hartford, we obtain the governing documents and establish the right insurer and plan administrator before anything is filed.

  • We Obtain and Review Your Entire Claim File: We request your complete file and review all of it, including internal claim notes, the reports and credentials of the physicians used, vocational analyses, and any surveillance.

  • We Document What the Insurer Never Asked For: Where the file has gaps in exactly the places your supporting evidence would be, we identify the records that were never requested and the providers who were never contacted, and we put that on the record.

  • We Identify Every Deadline in Your Policy: We locate the appeal deadline and the contractual deadline for filing suit, determine when each began to run, and build the appeal schedule around them.

  • We Work With Your Doctors and Retained Experts: We coordinate with your treating physicians for detailed reports on your restrictions and limitations, and where appropriate arrange functional capacity evaluations and vocational assessments.

  • We Respond Directly to the Insurer's Reviewers: We answer the file reviewers and examining physicians the insurer relied on, documenting the records they never received and the conclusions their own reports do not support.

  • We Handle Appeals and Litigation: If your appeal is denied, we are prepared to litigate in federal court on the record we built.


An Aetna long term disability claim can be a complicated process, and an incomplete record is a problem that usually cannot be fixed later. If you need help during the claims process, with appealing a claim denial, or with litigating a final adverse long term disability decision, The Maddox Firm can help. The experienced team at The Maddox Firm will examine your insurance policy, correspondence from your insurance company, medical records, and any other relevant documentation in order to give you personalized guidance on how we can help you win your long term disability claim. Our New Jersey and New York long term disability attorneys help clients nationwide.


bottom of page