top of page

What Employers Should Consider When Purchasing Group Disability Insurance

employer purchasing group disability insurance

In today’s dynamic and competitive job market, employers recognize the importance of offering comprehensive benefits to attract and retain top talent.  Group disability insurance stands as a crucial component in fostering a supportive and resilient workforce.  As employers navigate the complexities of selecting the right insurance coverage for their teams, understanding key considerations becomes paramount.

This article explores the essential factors employers should weigh when purchasing group disability insurance, ranging from the types of coverage available to customization options that align with the diverse needs of their employees.


Why is Group Disability Insurance Important for Employers?

Group disability insurance is a crucial component of a comprehensive employee benefits package.  It not only provides financial protection for employees during challenging times but also contributes to an employer’s efforts in attracting and retaining a talented and satisfied workforce.

Group disability insurance is a type of insurance coverage that provides income replacement to employees in the event they become unable to work due to a disability.

Here are a few reasons group disability insurance is important for employers:

  • Financial Protection for Employees: In the face of a disability, employees may face financial hardship due to medical expenses and loss of income. Group disability insurance ensures they continue to receive a portion of their salary, easing the financial burden.

  • Attracting and Retaining Talent: Offering comprehensive benefits, including disability insurance, makes an employer more attractive to potential hires and contributes to employee retention.  It demonstrates a commitment to the well-being of the workforce.

  • Legal Compliance: In some jurisdictions, employers may be legally required to provide disability insurance or comply with certain regulations related to employee benefits.  Offering group disability insurance helps businesses meet legal obligations.

  • Maintaining Employee Morale: Knowing they have financial protection in the event of a disability, employees can maintain peace of mind and focus on their recovery without the added stress of financial uncertainty.  Providing disability insurance also reflects a company’s commitment to employee welfare, contributing to a positive workplace culture.  This, in turn, can foster employee loyalty and engagement.

  • Productivity and Return-to-Work Support: Group disability insurance plans often include resources for rehabilitation and support services, helping employees reintegrate into the workforce after a disability.  This can enhance productivity and reduce the time it takes for employees to return to work.

  • Risk Mitigation for Employers: By offering disability insurance as part of the benefits package, employers can mitigate the financial risks associated with employee disabilities.  This proactive approach helps protect both employees and the business.


What Types of Group Disability Insurance Plans Are Available?

checkboxes for group disability insurance plans

Group disability insurance typically comes in two main forms: short term disability (“STD”) and long term disability (“LTD”).  STD provides coverage for a limited duration, often ranging from a few weeks to several months.  It is designed to replace a portion of an employee’s income during a temporary disability, such as recovery from surgery or a non-work-related injury.  LTD kicks in when a disability persists beyond the duration covered by STD.  It provides a more extended benefit period, often until the employee reaches retirement age or is able to return to work.

STD and LTD plans address different needs and durations of disabilities.  Short Term Disability (“STD”) plans are crucial for addressing sudden and short-term disabilities, such as recovery from surgery or non-work-related injuries.  These plans provide immediate financial support, offering employees a percentage of their pre-disability income during the initial phase of their disability.  The goal is to prevent financial strain and help cover essential living expenses during the short-term disability period.

Long Term Disability (“LTD”) plans are essential for addressing disabilities that persist beyond the coverage period of STD.  These plans offer a more extended benefit period, providing ongoing income replacement for employees facing prolonged or permanent disabilities.  The focus is on ensuring financial stability over the long term, and benefits are typically a percentage of the employee’s pre-disability income extended throughout the duration of the disability.

Many LTD plans include resources for rehabilitation and support services to assist employees in transitioning back to the workforce after a period of disability.  Rehabilitation services may encompass vocational training, counseling, or job placement assistance, contributing to a smoother return to work for employees who have experienced long-term disabilities.

Employers can tailor their group disability insurance offerings to balance the diverse needs of their workforce by providing a combination of Short Term Disability (“STD”) and Long Term Disability (“LTD”) coverage.  This approach ensures comprehensive protection against a range of disability scenarios, from short-term illnesses or injuries to more extended or permanent conditions, meeting the varied needs of employees within an organization.


How Much Disability Coverage Is Adequate?

Employers can determine the appropriate level of disability coverage for their employees by considering several factors and following a structured evaluation process:

  • Understand Employee Needs: Conduct surveys or engage in discussions to understand the diverse needs of the workforce.  Different employees may have varying financial obligations, lifestyles, and family structures, influencing their required level of coverage.

  • Evaluate Industry Standards: Research industry benchmarks and standards for disability insurance coverage.  Understanding what other companies in the same or similar industries offer can provide a reference point for determining competitive and adequate coverage.

  • Assess Employee Income: Consider the average income levels within the organization.  The coverage should aim to replace a significant portion of employees’ income during disability to maintain their financial stability.

  • Review Existing Benefits Package: Evaluate the existing benefits package to ensure that disability insurance complements other offerings, such as health insurance and retirement plans.  This ensures a well-rounded benefits package that addresses various aspects of employees’ well-being.

  • Analyze Budget Constraints: Assess the budget constraints of the organization.  Employers need to strike a balance between offering robust benefits and managing costs effectively.

  • Consider Industry Risks: Examine the nature of the industry and the associated risks.  Some industries may have higher rates of certain types of disabilities, influencing the necessary coverage levels.  For example, a physically demanding industry may require more extensive coverage for injuries.

  • Factor in Employee Demographics: Take into account the demographics of the workforce.  Younger employees may prioritize short-term disability coverage, while older employees may be more concerned about long-term disability protection.  Tailor coverage options accordingly.

  • Explore Customization Options: Work with insurance providers to explore customization options.  Some providers offer flexible plans that allow employers to tailor coverage levels, waiting periods, and benefit durations to better match the specific needs of their employees.

  • Regularly Review and Adjust: Periodically review the coverage levels and reassess the needs of the workforce.  Changes in the organization, industry, or employee demographics may warrant adjustments to the level of coverage over time.

By taking a holistic and analytical approach that considers both the financial well-being of employees and the strategic goals of the organization, employers can determine an appropriate level of disability coverage that meets the diverse needs of their workforce.  Regular reviews and open communication channels contribute to a benefits package that evolves in tandem with your organization’s and employees’ changing needs.


What Important Plan Terms Should Employers Know When Purchasing Group Disability Insurance?

group disability insurance plan terms

When purchasing group disability insurance, employers should be familiar with various plan terms to make informed decisions and effectively communicate details to their employees.  Here are important plan terms associated with group disability insurance:

  • Eligibility Waiting Period: The period of time that must elapse after an employee's hire date before certain benefits become effective. These benefits could include long term disability, and depending on state law, may include short term disability.

  • Active Employee Provisions: Similar to the eligibility waiting period provision, this provision will define which of your employees are "active employees" and thus covered by your disability plans. Typically, a minimum number of hours per week will qualify an individual as an active employee.

  • Pre-Existing Conditions: This provision is explained in more detail below. In summary, this provision will determine whether conditions that were diagnosed or treated, or should have been diagnosed or treated, will be covered by your short and long term disability plans.

  • Elimination Period: The period of time that must elapse after a covered disability begins before benefit payments are initiated.  Employers should understand the waiting period, as it influences when employees will start receiving disability benefits.

  • Benefit Duration: The maximum period for which disability benefits will be paid under the policy.  Knowing the benefit duration helps employers assess the long-term financial impact on employees and plan for potential long-term disabilities.

  • Definition of Disability: The criteria used to determine if an employee is eligible for disability benefits.  Understanding how disability is defined in the policy is crucial to determine when an employee qualifies for benefits.

  • Benefit Amount: The percentage of the employee’s pre-disability income that will be paid as disability benefits.  Employers need to know the benefit amount to assess the adequacy of income replacement for employees during a disability.

  • Own Occupation vs. Any Occupation: Specifies whether disability benefits are based on the inability to perform one’s own occupation or any occupation.  Understanding this distinction is crucial, as it affects the likelihood of an employee qualifying for disability benefits.

  • Residual Disability Benefits: Provides partial disability benefits if an employee can work but has a reduced income due to a covered disability.  Employers should be aware of the availability of residual benefits to address cases where employees can work in a limited capacity.

  • Rehabilitation and Return-to-Work Provisions: Outlines the support and resources available to help disabled employees return to work.  Employers should be aware of provisions that facilitate the reintegration of employees into the workforce after a disability.

  • Exclusions and Limitations: Describes specific conditions, situations, or events that are not covered by the disability insurance policy.  Employers need to be aware of exclusions and limitations to communicate accurately the scope of coverage to employees.

  • Renewal Terms: Specifies the conditions and terms under which the policy can be renewed after its initial term.  Employers should be familiar with renewal terms to ensure the continuity of disability insurance coverage.

  • Conversion Options: Allows employees leaving the company to convert their group disability coverage to an individual policy.  Knowing conversion options is essential for employees who may lose coverage upon leaving the organization.

  • Employee Contribution: If applicable, the portion of the premium that employees are required to contribute.  Employers should communicate clearly whether employees are responsible for any part of the premium and the associated contribution.

  • Buy-Up Class: You may offer a "buy-up" option for employees that want to elect more generous provisions, such as a higher benefit percentage, more lenient standard of disability, or more expansive definition of pre-disability income. This is a good option for employees with a lower risk tolerance.

Understanding these plan terms is vital for employers when selecting and managing group disability insurance.  It enables them to make informed decisions, effectively communicate with employees, and ensure that the coverage aligns with the needs of the workforce.


What are the Premium Costs and Cost Structures of Disability Insurance?

Premium costs for group disability insurance are determined based on several factors, including the type of coverage, the size and demographics of the employee group, industry risk factors, and the chosen benefit levels.  Employers often collaborate with insurance providers to tailor coverage that aligns with the needs of their workforce.

The calculation of group disability insurance premiums involves assessing the risk associated with the covered population.  Insurance companies consider factors such as the age, health status, and occupation of employees, as well as historical disability claims data.  This information helps determine the likelihood of claims and sets the premium rates accordingly.

Different cost structures exist for group disability insurance, allowing employers to choose options that suit their budgetary constraints and coverage goals.  Common cost structures include experience-rated premiums, where rates are based on the group’s historical claims experience, and composite-rated premiums, which offer a flat rate for all employees regardless of individual risk factors.

Employers must strike a balance between cost-effectiveness and comprehensive coverage.  While it may be tempting to minimize premiums, providing inadequate coverage can lead to financial challenges for employees and potential talent retention issues for employers.

Therefore, it’s essential for employers to conduct a thorough analysis of their workforce’s needs, assess industry benchmarks, and collaborate with insurance providers to customize a plan that offers meaningful protection without compromising financial feasibility.  Regular reviews of the plan, adjustments to coverage based on changing circumstances, and clear communication with employees contribute to a well-balanced and effective group disability insurance strategy.


Are Pre-Existing Conditions Covered?

pre-existing conditions

Group disability insurance plans typically have provisions regarding pre-existing conditions, and these provisions can vary among different insurance providers.  Pre-existing conditions are health issues that an individual has before the effective date of the disability insurance coverage.  Here’s how group disability insurance plans commonly handle pre-existing conditions:

  • Look-Back Period: Insurance plans may include a “look-back” period during which they assess an individual’s medical history to identify pre-existing conditions.  This period typically ranges from three to twelve months before the policy becomes effective.

  • Exclusionary Periods: Some group disability insurance plans may impose exclusionary periods during which benefits are not payable for disabilities resulting from pre-existing conditions.  This period is usually limited, often ranging from three to twelve months.

  • Credit for Prior Coverage: Employees with prior disability insurance coverage may receive credit for the time they were covered.  This credit can sometimes shorten or eliminate exclusionary periods related to pre-existing conditions.

  • Eligible Employee and Active Employee Requirements: Group disability insurance plans may require employees to be actively at work for a certain period or be scheduled for a certain minimum number of hours before coverage becomes effective.  This helps ensure that individuals with part-time schedules or employed during a probationary period are not immediately eligible for benefits upon obtaining coverage.

  • Limited Coverage for Pre-Existing Conditions: Some plans may offer limited coverage for pre-existing conditions during the initial policy period, providing a reduced benefit amount or imposing specific limitations until the exclusionary period expires.

To navigate these provisions, employers should thoroughly review and understand the pre-existing condition provisions within the group disability insurance plan.  This includes the look-back period, exclusionary periods, and any limitations on coverage.  Make sure to educate employees about the pre-existing condition provisions, ensuring that they understand how these provisions may impact the availability and timing of disability benefits.

Employers may explore alternative options for employees with pre-existing conditions, such as supplemental coverage or voluntary plans that offer additional protection.

By understanding the nuances of pre-existing condition provisions and proactively addressing concerns, employers can ensure that coverage meets the needs of employees while considering any limitations or exclusions related to pre-existing conditions.


What Is the Process for Filing Claims?

disability insurance claim form

The claims process for employees who need to utilize disability insurance typically involves several steps.  Here’s a general overview of the process:

  • Notification of Disability: The process begins when an employee experiences a disability that may qualify for disability insurance benefits.  The employee should promptly notify the employer and the insurance provider about their disability and intent to file a claim.

  • Submission of Claim Form: The employee, with the assistance of the employer or HR department, completes and submits a disability insurance claim form provided by the insurance provider.  This form gathers essential information about the employee’s medical condition, the onset of the disability, and other relevant details.

  • Medical Documentation: The employee is typically required to provide medical documentation supporting the disability claim.  This may include medical records, physician statements, diagnostic test results, and other relevant documentation verifying the nature and extent of the disability.

  • Claim Review by Insurer: The insurance provider reviews the submitted claim and supporting documentation to assess the validity of the disability and determine eligibility for benefits.  This review process may involve consulting with medical professionals or specialists.

  • Approval or Denial of Claim: Based on the review, the insurance provider will either approve or deny the disability insurance claim.  If approved, the employee will receive a notification detailing the benefit amount, duration, and any other relevant terms.  If denied, the employee will be provided with reasons for the denial.

  • Benefit Payments: If the claim is approved, the insurance provider initiates benefit payments according to the terms of the policy.  Payments are typically made on a regular schedule (e.g., monthly) and represent a percentage of the employee’s pre-disability income.

  • Regular Updates and Monitoring: During the period of disability, the insurance provider may require regular updates from the employee, including medical status updates and information about any changes that may affect the continuation of benefits.

  • Return-to-Work Coordination: In cases where the employee is medically cleared to return to work, the insurance provider may coordinate with the employer to facilitate a smooth transition back to the workplace.  This may involve a phased return, workplace accommodations, or rehabilitation services.

  • Appeal Process (if applicable): If a claim is denied, the employee has the right to appeal the decision.  This often involves submitting additional documentation or providing further clarification regarding the disability.  Employers can assist employees in navigating the appeals process.

Throughout the claims process, effective communication between the employee, employer, and insurance provider is crucial.  Employers can play a supportive role by guiding employees through the necessary steps, facilitating communication with the insurer, and ensuring a smooth transition when the employee is ready to return to work.


Can Employees Customize Their Coverage?

Yes, many group disability insurance plans offer employees the option to customize their coverage based on individual needs.  This customization allows employees to tailor their disability insurance to better suit their unique circumstances.

Here are some common customization options:

  • Benefit Amount: Employees may have the flexibility to choose the benefit amount they receive if they become disabled.  This amount is often expressed as a percentage of their pre-disability income.

  • Elimination Period: The elimination period, also known as the waiting period, is the duration an employee must wait after the onset of disability before receiving benefits.  Employees may have choices regarding the length of this waiting period.

  • Partial Disability Coverage: Some plans offer the option for partial disability coverage, providing benefits if an employee can work but experiences a reduction in income due to a covered disability.

  • Cost-of-Living Adjustments (“COLA”): Employees may have the option to include cost-of-living adjustments in their coverage, ensuring that disability benefits keep pace with inflation.

  • Return-to-Work Incentives: Certain plans provide incentives for employees to return to work after a disability.  This could include a partial benefit while working part-time or incentives for participating in rehabilitation programs.

  • Supplemental Coverage: Employees may have the option to purchase supplemental coverage beyond the basic disability insurance provided by the employer.  This additional coverage can enhance the overall level of protection.

  • Voluntary Buy-Up Options: Some group disability insurance plans offer voluntary buy-up options, allowing employees to purchase additional coverage by paying a higher premium.

Employees can typically choose from these options during open enrollment periods or when initially enrolling in the disability insurance plan.  Offering customization options empowers employees to align their disability coverage with their specific financial needs, lifestyle, and risk tolerance.  Employers should ensure that employees are well-informed about these customization options and encourage them to select coverage that best meets their individual circumstances.


What are the Policy Renewal Terms and Conditions?

The renewal terms of a group disability insurance policy are influenced by several factors that employers should consider to secure long-term, stable coverage for their workforce. These factors include:

  • Claims Experience: The historical claims experience of the group can significantly impact renewal terms.  If there have been a higher number of disability claims, it may lead to adjustments in premium rates or coverage terms during renewal.

  • Workforce Demographics: Changes in the demographics of the workforce, such as an aging population or shifts in employee health profiles, can affect the overall risk profile.  Insurers may adjust renewal terms based on these demographic factors.

  • Industry Trends: Trends within the industry or broader economic conditions can influence renewal terms.  For example, if there is an increased incidence of disabilities in a specific industry, insurers may adjust premiums accordingly.

  • Policy Utilization: The extent to which employees utilize the disability insurance policy can impact renewal terms.  High utilization rates may lead to adjustments in premium rates or changes in coverage terms.

  • Market Conditions: General market conditions within the insurance industry can affect renewal terms.  Economic factors, interest rates, and overall market trends can impact how insurers approach policy renewals.

  • Underwriting Considerations: The underwriting process during policy renewal assesses the overall risk profile of the group.  Changes in underwriting considerations, such as advancements in risk assessment methodologies, may influence renewal terms.

  • Employer’s Risk Management Practices: Employers’ efforts in promoting workplace safety and implementing effective risk management practices can positively influence renewal terms.  A proactive approach to employee well-being may be viewed favorably by insurers.

  • Employee Health and Wellness Programs: Implementation of employee health and wellness programs can positively impact renewal terms by promoting a healthier workforce and potentially reducing the likelihood of disabilities.

To secure long-term, stable coverage for their workforce, employers should proactively manage these factors.  This involves ongoing communication with the insurance provider, a commitment to employee well-being, and a strategic approach to risk management.  

Employers should also stay informed about industry trends, leverage available resources to enhance workplace safety, and continually assess and adjust their benefits strategy to align with the evolving needs of the workforce.


How Can The Maddox Firm Help My Employees With Their Short or Long Term Disability Claims?

The Maddox Firm | Long Term Disability & ERISA

At The Maddox Firm, we have helped hundreds of professionals navigate the intricacies of short and long term disability claims.  Our dedicated team employs a comprehensive approach, ensuring that every step of the claims process is handled with diligence and expertise.  

Here’s how we can assist your employees:

  • Examining the Insurance Policy: Our first step is a meticulous examination of the insurance policy.  We delve into the terms, conditions, and coverage details to ensure a clear understanding of the benefits your employees are entitled to under your specific plan.

  • Communicating with the Insurance Company: We handle all communications with your insurance company, managing all correspondence on your employees' behalf.  This includes responding to requests for information, seeking clarifications, and ensuring that the claims process goes as smoothly as possible.

  • Gathering Medical Evidence: To bolster the claim, The Maddox Firm works closely with treating healthcare providers to gather comprehensive and compelling evidence of disability.  This includes obtaining medical records, opinions from treating physicians, and other relevant documentation that substantiates the case.

  • Recommending Further Assessments: In some cases, additional assessments, such as medical testing or vocational evaluations, may be recommended to strengthen the evidentiary foundation of your claim.  Our team will guide you through this process, ensuring that all necessary assessments are conducted with your employees' best interests in mind.

  • Preparing and Submitting the Claim: Crafting a well-prepared claim is crucial.  We take the lead in assembling all required documentation, drafting persuasive narratives, and ensuring that your claim is submitted accurately and within stipulated timelines.

  • Appealing a Denied Claim: Should the claim face denial, we are well-versed in the intricacies of the appeals process.  The Maddox Firm will meticulously review the reasons for denial, strategize an effective appeal, and submit compelling arguments to overturn the decision.

  • Litigating the Claim in Court: In cases where litigation becomes necessary, The Maddox Firm can sue the insurance company.

Whether you are looking for assistance in navigating the claims process, appealing a claim denial, or litigating a final adverse decision, The Maddox Firm can help with your short or long term disability claim.  The experienced team at The Maddox Firm will examine your insurance policy, correspondence from your insurance company, medical records, and any other relevant documentation in order to give you personalized guidance on how we can help you win your short and/or long term disability claim. Our New Jersey and New York long term disability attorneys help clients nationwide.





bottom of page